The Broken Hallelujah: The Brokenness Of Suffering
The Broken Hallelujah:
The Brokenness of Suffering
In my current series of lessons, I am discussing The Broken Hallelujah, a phrase derived from the Leonard Cohen song, Hallelujah (see last week’s article, blog, and YouTube sermon). The full title of the series sounds like a research paper topic, but it helps me refine my thought processes—The Broken Hallelujah: Rescuing the Christian Life from the Tyranny of Triumphalism. Below, is a description of Christian Triumphalism gleaned from a synthesis of several internet sources.
Characteristics of Christian Triumphalism
Focus on Victory:
It emphasizes the “victorious Christian life” as an upward trajectory of overcoming sin and achieving righteousness, potentially leading to a performance-based view of faith.
Political and Cultural Engagement:
It views political affairs as central to the Christian life, with a commission to “win the culture wars” and mobilize Christians around a political agenda.
“Kingdom Now” Theology:
This is a belief that the kingdom of God is already fully present, allowing for the immediate realization of all its benefits (e.g., health and wealth), an idea sometimes called over-realized eschatology.
Dominionism:
Some adherents believe God intends Christians to take dominion over the world, leading to the imposition of Christian values on society.
Lack of Humility:
The emphasis on human pride and achievement can result in a lack of humility, self-criticism, and a failure to acknowledge ongoing struggles and sin.
Dangers and Criticisms of Christian Triumphalism
Disregard for Present Suffering:
By overly emphasizing future glory and present victory, triumphalism can overlook the reality of suffering, weakness, and the ongoing spiritual battle in a fallen world.
Inauthentic Faith:
The pressure to appear triumphant can discourage confession of sin and struggles, leading to a crushing burden for those dealing with depression or anxiety.
Pride and Boasting:
It can lead to pride, a sense of self-righteousness, and an assertion of superiority over other groups or beliefs.
Misinterpretation of Scripture:
Critics argue that this approach can be a distorted understanding of biblical passages that actually describe a life characterized by a tension between glory and suffering.
Historical Link to Imperialism:
In historical contexts, triumphalism has been intertwined with political and military conquest and the expansion of Christianity through power and domination.
This series is not intended to address the political or imperialistic dimensions of triumphalism. However, we would be wise to prayerfully consider and evaluate the current surge of Christian Nationalism in a sound theological context.
Below are some hotlinks for those of you who receive the bulletin by email or are reading on our church blog (https://boisecoc.org/blog/). These links will give you more information
What is triumphalism? Should Christians be triumphalists? | GotQuestions.org
Gordon Fee on “Triumphalistic” Theology – Questions That Matter
Balance: Combating Christian Triumphalism | Steve Schramm
Three Dangers of an Over-Realized Eschatology
How Two-Kingdoms Doctrine Helps Political Discourse
Sunday’s message will deal with the Brokenness of Suffering.
Join us as we learn to praise God in our brokenness……
Joey